I think 3D is much better although I don't mind either one, but top down feels really old and dated. By the way, is there a new Zelda game that needs to come out?
2D Zelda is the best. I feel the same way about 2D Pokemon games. I mean...Wind Waker is my favorite Zelda game, and it's in 3D. However, I'm not sure if the less stylized Zelda games (Twilight Princess, even OoT/MM) really work for me visually. I LOVE Wind Waker and Spirit Tracks, however. I feel like the more realistic Zelda games aren't very true to the feel of the games themselves. Zelda games are fun, they're magical, they're silly. I feel like it's hard to get that vibe across in a game that looks like it's trying to look like Skyrim for kids.
